It all started when Rob made a cold peanut butter sandwich, with butter on both sides of the bread, and his entire family acted like he’d committed a serious culinary crime.
Turns out, this is how Rob’s always made his sandwiches. Butter with peanut butter. Butter with Nutella. Even butter with sultanas (yes, really).
Ash? Totally horrified. She says butter belongs nowhere near peanut butter or Nutella. But when we asked you, the phones lit up. One listener said eating peanut butter without butter is like a pie without sauce. Another claimed the perfect butter-to-peanut-butter ratio depends on the weather. And someone even declared butter “the first step of every sandwich.”
The plot twist? Ash remembered her great-aunt making triangle PB+Nutella sandwiches… with butter. And yep, she refused to eat those.
Finally, the tally for the big question is in:
